Living With Endometriosis

  • Home
  • [About]
  • [What Is Endometriosis?]
  • [Support]
  • [Endo Organisations]
  • “…but have you tried…”
  • About Me
  • Alternative Medicine
  • Applying for Disability
  • Be Aware
  • Endometriosis and Menopause
  • Fallen Endo Siblings – A Memorial Page
  • Filing for Medicare health benefits
  • Filing for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI)
  • Hormonal Suppression
  • In The News – Pharmaceuticals Can Be Dangerous
  • Is Endometriosis A Cancer?
  • Job Discrimination
  • March is National Endometriosis Awareness Month
  • Myths About Endometriosis
  • Old Wives’ Tales
  • Online Support For Endometriosis
  • Organisations
  • Our Life In Comics
  • Pain Medication
  • Pharmaceutically-run Marketing Websites
  • Public Service Announcement
  • Research and Medical Journals
  • Surgery
  • We Are Not Seekers
  • What I Should Have Said
  • What Is Endometriosis?
  • YouTube – Endometriosis Video Blogs

16

Nov

Treating Endometriosis as a Women’s Disease Hurts Patients of All Genders

Posted by admin 

Treating Endometriosis as a Women’s Disease Hurts Patients of All Genders

Living with endo is already hard when you’re a white cis woman. For LGBTQ people dealing with a “women’s disease,” it’s especially painful.
by Emily Lipstein

In 2016, Les Henderson’s lung collapsed twice in two weeks. Henderson, a Black, masc-of-center lesbian who uses she and they pronouns, was diagnosed with thoracic endometriosis after waking up from surgery to fix the collapsed lung—and only because her surgeon thought to connect it with the timing of her period. 

Henderson, now 36, was diagnosed with endometriosis when they were 29 after years of struggling with terrible pain during their period. It wasn’t until they were recovering from their lung collapses a few years later that they learned endometriosis could be found elsewhere in the body. 

They blamed this delay on the inadequate care they received from biased doctors. “I’ve gone through the ringer with several OBGYNs. If I were a typical feminine, cis straight woman, I’d be taken a lot differently,” they said. “Masculine people aren’t expected to hurt, aren’t expected to be weak. And that’s something that I have definitely noticed with the unconcern and disregard I’ve gotten with this.”

“What is it about myself that’s not deserving of endo care?” said Henderson. “What is it about this trans person that you can’t properly help? What is it about this Black woman that you can’t help?”

It takes nearly a decade for most patients to receive a diagnosis of endometriosis, which is said to impact one in 10 people assigned female at birth. When a patient is LGBTQ, diagnosis can take a lot longer—in part because queer and trans people have statistically lower access to medical care than cis patients in all senses, but also because of the way endo is characterized as a “women’s illness.” 

“We consider [endometriosis] this disease of ‘menstruating females,’” said Heather Guidone, Patient Care Advocate and Program Director at the Center for Endometriosis Care in Atlanta, Georgia. “What about gender-diverse folks?” 

“[Endometriosis is] so grounded in this notion that [it’s] a disease of affluent white women,” said Guidone. “If you don’t look like what you think an endometriosis patient is ‘supposed’ to look like, your disease may be overlooked.” According to Guidone, this bias is predicated on how endometriosis is misunderstood on a medical level. “It all links back to the idea that this is a pelvic disease, this is a womb disease. Literally, this is a disease that’s found outside of the uterus.”

Although endometriosis is linked to the hormone fluctuations associated with menstruation, “Endo is not just painful periods,” said Jessica Shim, a gynecologist at Boston Children’s Hospital. The disease is caused by tissue that’s similar to (but biologically different from) the tissue that lines the inside of the uterus that grows outside of the uterus. It can adhere to parts of the reproductive system and other pelvic organs. Endometriotic lesions can also be found outside the pelvic region. The condition can cause severe pain, infertility, pain during sexual penetration and orgasm, digestive issues, and brain fog, among other debilitating symptoms. 

Endometriosis is commonly framed as largely impacting white, middle-class women in their “childbearing years.” This stereotype persists because prominent early theories of endometriosis (like the rest of gynecology) were rooted in racism and sexism. For nearly 100 years, the gynecologist John A. Sampson’s theory that endometriosis was caused by “retrograde menstruation,” or menses that flow backwards into the pelvis, has been the basis for how doctors approach treatment. While it may be one cause of endometriosis, research shows most people who menstruate exhibit retrograde menstruation. For decades, pregnancy and hysterectomy were touted as “cures,” and today, birth control and other medications that mimic pregnancy or menopause are still prescribed to treat symptoms of endometriosis.

Endometriosis is a disease process driven by estrogen, according to Shanti Mohling, a gynecological surgeon based in Portland. Endometriosis doesn’t require the ovaries to produce estrogen: It actually makes its own. This means that a hysterectomy, inducing menopause, or pregnancy won’t stop the disease.

“The effects of endo aren’t just related to pregnancy, conception, and menstruation,” said Cara Jones, a professor of womens’ studies at California State University who uses she and they pronouns. Her research uses feminist, queer, and disability studies as a framework for understanding endometriosis as a “dynamic disability.” According to Jones, “It affects the digestive system, the musculoskeletal system, and different organs. It affects mood. It’s a whole-body condition.”

Joe V. Meigs, a once-celebrated Harvard gynecologist, is largely to blame for 20th century doctors’ obsession with endometriosis and pregnancy. As Jones wrote in the 2020 article “Queering Gendered Disabilities,” “Meigs spent his career encouraging physicians to compel upper-middle class white women to have children early and often,” due to his belief that “endometriosis developed from failing to use their reproductive systems.” His work made a target of career women, since many endometriosis patients were diagnosed after discovering their infertility in their late 30s or early 40s. Meigs even argued for policies that would pay white men more so their wives could stop working and focus on having babies.

Many health care professionals have rightfully thrown out the outdated and incorrect guidance popularized by Sampson and Meigs. But many leading medical institutions continue to define and diagnose endometriosis as anchored in white, cis, heterosexual reproduction. “Many clinicians are unable to disentangle gender from anatomy when it comes to providing care,” said Frances Grimstad, another gynecologist at Boston Childrens’ Hospital.

According to the New York Times, most medical schools only spend five hours educating students on LGBTQ-specific practices, which leaves patients to educate their own doctors while in the exam room, or stay mum entirely. This can mean that queer and trans people may be hesitant to seek treatment for endometriosis, in part because relying on trans and queer patients to advocate for themselves on an individual level can be exhausting for them and counterproductive to their path towards healing. “I’m usually fine answering questions and educating people,” said Ryan McGill, a 27-year-old transmasculine non-binary person. “But: Right now it feels like there’s like a gremlin in my stomach trying to escape. Can you please help me?”

Kat Aschman, who is 24 and non-binary, delayed going to the doctor after multiple bad experiences. “I didn’t want to have to go into a doctor’s office and be told, ‘Oh, that’s just a women’s health issue.’ I didn’t want to be labeled as a woman in order to seek treatment. So I avoided treatment until I really needed to.”

Some of the people VICE spoke to made the choice to not disclose their gender identity to medical providers in the past in order to avoid mistreatment. “I’m not entirely sure that my doctor understood that I wasn’t a woman,” Aschman said. “I just wanted to get relief, because it was impacting my ability just to function.”

“I haven’t ever talked to one of my endometriosis doctors about gender identity,” said Kat Eckert, a queer, non-binary person who uses she and they pronouns. “I don’t know if it would be a safe space to bring that up.” These experiences are backed up by a 2015 study, which found that a majority of healthcare providers show implicit preference for straight patients over queer ones.

Inadequate training around queer healthcare issues can be dangerous for LGBTQ patients—especially for trans patients undergoing gender-affirming treatments. After being prescribed birth control to manage their endo symptoms, McGill asked their doctor about what drug interactions the birth control would have with the testosterone they took as a gender-affirming medication. The doctor had no idea what interactions existed between the two drugs. 

“I’m not gonna take something if you don’t know how it’s going to interact with my particular body,” McGill said. “If my doctor handed me medication and is not sure of herself, why would I feel comfortable putting that in my body?”

Going to a queer-friendly clinic isn’t necessarily the answer, either. Just because a physician provides gender affirming healthcare doesn’t mean they’re automatically more understanding of pelvic pain than the average doctor. “It’s challenging,” Henderson explained, “[Sometimes] you find a queer-[friendly] doctor, but they know nothing of endo. [Or] you find an endo specialist, but they’re biased.”

Emory Pringnitz—a 24-year-old with endometriosis who identifies as queer, bisexual, and non-binary—had the former experience with one OBGYN, which soured the identity-affirming aspects of their care. “That’s when I decided that the lovely bedside manner she was giving me wasn’t worth not seeing any symptom relief,” they said.

Trans healthcare isn’t exempt from cissexism. Some medical providers won’t think to diagnose endometriosis in transmasculine patients, even when they present classic signs of the disease, because of their gender identity. As Shim explained, some patients and doctors believe that being on T can solve pelvic pain and painful periods by stopping them altogether. When the bleeding and pain continue, many doctors have no idea what to do.

Cori Smith, a trans man with endo, described receiving biased care in a blog written for the Endometriosis Association of America. His lapsed symptoms came back after he started T, and he requested a hysterectomy to relieve his pain. While the surgeon removed Smith’s two swollen ovaries, he refused to remove his uterus, “allegedly telling Smith that he ‘didn’t feel comfortable aiding in [his] transition,’” according to the piece.

“Uterectomies are overprescribed for cisgender women with endo, yet trans men are denied the same treatment,” summarized Jones in “Queering Gendered Disabilities.” But Henderson described an experience where one OBGYN suggested they get a hysterectomy after they disclosed their queer identity because, Henderson said, the provider claimed not to “understand [their] lifestyle.” Racism may have been part of why this doctor pushed Henderson to get a hysterectomy: Black women in America receive hysterectomies at rates far surpassing white women; a whistleblower recently brought light to the eugenicist practice of forcing hysterectomies on Latinx women in ICE detention centers. 

“Women of color are being offered a hysterectomy almost right off the bat for endometriosis,” said Jones. “We have these divergent tracks for different groups of people experiencing the same thing.” 

This June, Grimstad and Shim published a study looking at how endometriosis presents in 35 trans adolescent patients experiencing pelvic pain after starting to transition on T. Only seven were evaluated for endometriosis through laparoscopy, which is the only way to affirmatively make a diagnosis. “We found that there was a 100 percent detection rate of endometriosis in these patients,” said Shim. Their study should encourage doctors to take time to investigate the cause of transitioning patients’ pain, as many incorrectly believe that being on T should stop endometriosis symptoms.

Patients can’t sit around and wait for research to catch up to their lives. It’s up to clinicians to take steps to address biases right now. The people VICE spoke to suggested that creating a welcoming environment, being inclusive on intake forms, and having providers share their own pronouns is an easy and necessary place to start. 

“I don’t care whether they’re the receptionist—all the way up to the surgeon, everyone needs to have training,” said Henderson.

“You don’t need to have a budget meeting and in a coalition get together to decide to say ‘people with periods’ instead of ‘women,’” said Guidone, who believes that the best way to give patients care is to actually ask them what they want—whether it’s preserving their fertility, getting rid of pain, or both of those things, or something more. 

As patients await these changes, trans men will still develop pelvic pain and non-binary people will be misgendered in medical settings as they seek care.

The gendered biases, misconceptions, bigotry, and simply bad information that are inherent to endometriosis have endlessly frustrated Henderson in their attempts to access treatment. “If you can’t check your prejudices when you’re serving the public, you need to take your ass to another profession,” they said. “Health care is no place to be when you can’t get your biases in check.”

Emily Lipstein is the Senior Social Editor for Motherboard. Follow her on Twitter.

Published in Endometriosis Awareness

Related Articles

  • Virtual WorldWide EndoMarch (March 28th, 2020)
  • For transgender men, pain of menstruation is more than just physical (January 18th, 2020)
  • Definition of Endometriosis (January 18th, 2020)
  • Why It’s Harder For People Of Colour To Get Diagnosed With Endometriosis (March 10th, 2019)
  • This professor suffers from a mystery disease, so she developed an app to track its effects (March 7th, 2019)

No user responded in this post

Subscribe to this post comment rss or trackback url

Search

Don't Have Endo? Please Read!

  • The Letter From Survivors

  • Public Service Announcement!

  • We Are Not Seekers

  • What I Should Have Said

  • "...but have you tried..."

  • Sick Humor: The top ten worst
    suggestions commonly given to
    someone with a chronic illness


  • Our Life In Comics

Important Pages

  • Endopaedia

  • Research and Medical Journals

  • Myths about Endometriosis

  • YouTube Video Blogs

  • Applying For Disability

  • Be Aware!

  • Endo and Menopause

  • Is Endo A Cancer?

  • Job Discrimination

  • Fallen Endo Siblings

Mankoski Pain Scale

0 - Pain Free

1 - Very minor annoyance - occasional
minor twinges. No medication needed.

2 - Minor Annoyance - occasional
strong twinges.
No medication needed.

3 - Annoying enough to be distracting.
Mild painkillers take care of it.
(Aspirin, Ibuprofen.)

4 - Can be ignored if you are really
involved in your work, but still
distracting. Mild painkillers remove
pain for 3-4 hours.

5 - Can't be ignored for more than 30
minutes. Mild painkillers ameliorate
pain for 3-4 hours.

6 - Can't be ignored for any length of
time, but you can still go to work and
participate in social activities.
Stronger painkillers (Codeine,
narcotics) reduce pain for 3-4 hours.

7 - Makes it difficult to concentrate,
interferes with sleep. You can still
function with effort. Stronger
painkillers are only partially effective.

8 - Physical activity severely limited.
You can read and converse with effort.
Nausea and dizziness set in as factors
of pain.

9 - Unable to speak. Crying out or
moaning uncontrollably - near delirium.

10 - Unconscious. Pain makes you
pass out.

© Andrea Mankoski

Organisations

  • Endometriosis Association

  • Endometriosis Research Center

  • endometriosis.org

  • World Endometriosis Foundation

  • Center for Endometriosis Care

  • World Endometriosis Society

Symptom Tracking

  • CureTogether.com
    - Compare symptoms with people like you,
    Find treatments that work, optimize your
    health


  • PatientsLikeMe.com
    - Real-time pain mapping, monitoring,
    analysis. Community.


  • MyMonthlyCycles.com
    - free personalized tools to track, monitor,
    and manage your mo nthly menstrual cycles!

Endo Products


  • Naturally Hip
    - cloth menstrual pads

  • EndoFEMM
    - Microwavable corn-filled cloth heating
    pads. (mention you saw them here and get
    10% off your order!)


  • Endo Awareness swag
    - As found on Etsy

Blogroll

  • Antonia's Epic Endo Journey
  • Canadian Girl In Pain
  • Chances Our
  • Chronic Healing
  • Dear Thyroid
  • Endo Empowered
  • Endo Friendo
  • Endo Times
  • Endo Writer
  • Endometriosis: The Silent Life Sentence
  • Field Notes from an Evolutionary Psychologist
  • Foxy In The Waiting Room
  • Get Well blog
  • I Will Not Suffer In Silence
  • Lupron Journal
  • My Journey With Endometriosis
  • My Life With Endo & Infertility
  • Pop Goes The Feasible
  • Reading List & Resources for chronic pain, including endometriosis
  • Resilience
  • Sallie Speaks
  • SansUterus
  • Surviving Endo
  • The Ins and Outs of Endo
  • Whispered Words …
  • Yellow Paper Dress

Categories

  • Administrative (10)
  • Alternative medicine (4)
  • Autoimmune (5)
  • Biographies (12)
  • Biology (14)
  • books (3)
  • cancer risk (17)
  • Centers for Disease Control (1)
  • Chronic Pain (7)
  • diet (9)
  • doctors (7)
  • Endometriosis Awareness (135)
  • Featured (34)
  • Food and Drug Administration (6)
  • Government-involvement (9)
  • Heart risk (1)
  • Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) (3)
  • Hysterectomy (5)
  • Infertility (1)
  • Inspirational (3)
  • Insurance industry (3)
  • Malpractice (4)
  • Medical industry (5)
  • Menopause (1)
  • News article (102)
  • Outrageous (19)
  • pain management (3)
  • Pharmaceuticals (13)
  • Pseudoscience (1)
  • Research (71)
  • Suicide (2)
  • Support and networking (8)
  • Tips and advice (11)
  • Uncategorized (10)
November 2020
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  
« Mar   Mar »

Archives

  • March 2021 (7)
  • November 2020 (1)
  • March 2020 (2)
  • January 2020 (2)
  • March 2019 (7)
  • March 2018 (8)
  • March 2017 (12)
  • April 2016 (1)
  • March 2016 (8)
  • February 2016 (1)
  • August 2015 (1)
  • March 2015 (17)
  • December 2014 (1)
  • July 2014 (1)
  • April 2014 (2)
  • March 2014 (3)
  • May 2013 (1)
  • March 2013 (31)
  • July 2012 (1)
  • April 2012 (2)
  • March 2012 (9)
  • February 2012 (5)
  • January 2012 (2)
  • December 2011 (1)
  • November 2011 (1)
  • August 2011 (1)
  • July 2011 (1)
  • March 2011 (3)
  • January 2011 (5)
  • December 2010 (3)
  • November 2010 (1)
  • October 2010 (1)
  • September 2010 (2)
  • August 2010 (2)
  • July 2010 (2)
  • May 2010 (1)
  • April 2010 (8)
  • March 2010 (4)
  • February 2010 (10)
  • January 2010 (2)
  • December 2009 (1)
  • November 2009 (4)
  • October 2009 (2)
  • September 2009 (3)
  • August 2009 (4)
  • June 2009 (2)
  • April 2009 (2)
  • March 2009 (38)
  • February 2009 (9)
  • January 2009 (15)
  • December 2008 (12)
  • November 2008 (8)
  • January 2008 (1)

Syndication

  • Add blog to any reader

  • Comments RSS

Recent Post

  • “I thought it was normal to have pain with a period…”
  • Can special diets, herbal supplements or exercise cure endometriosis?
  • Endo Awareness Month – Does hysterectomy cure endometriosis?
  • Endo Awareness Month: Is Endometriosis a rare disease?
  • Endo affects our trans siblings, too.
  • Endo Awareness Month – Does Negative Thinking Cause Painful Periods?
  • Endo Awareness Month – What Is Endometriosis?
  • Treating Endometriosis as a Women’s Disease Hurts Patients of All Genders
  • Virtual WorldWide EndoMarch
  • Coronavirus (COVID-19) and Endometriosis

Recent Comments

  • Kathy in A Breakthrough In A Disease That No One Likes To T…
  • Jenn in Unbelievable doctors in the 21st century
  • admin in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • That Girl with Endo in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • I Will Not Suffer In Silence »… in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • That Girl with Endo in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • steph in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • JennM in Peggy Santa Maria - a saint to endo sisters!
  • I Will Not Suffer In Silence »… in Genetic variants on chromosome 1 and 7 more likely…
  • steph in Dr. David Redwine faces Oregon state Medical Board…
© 2008 Living With Endometriosis is proudly powered by WordPress
Designed by Roam2Rome